Commander mana base guide showing fetchlands and land count advice for EDH deckbuilding

How many lands should a Commander deck run?

Few things in Commander feel worse than sitting at a table doing absolutely nothing because you missed your land drops.

And yet, one of the most common mistakes in EDH deckbuilding is still:

not running enough lands.

Almost every Commander player has done it at some point.

You build an exciting deck, start adding powerful cards, and eventually think:

“Maybe I can cut two lands for more action.”

That is usually where the suffering begins. 

The biggest Commander trap:

greed

Commander players are naturally greedy deckbuilders.

Everybody wants:

  • more bombs
  • more synergy
  • more draw
  • more combos
  • more flashy cards

Nobody gets excited adding land number 37.

But consistency wins far more games than greed does.

A deck that functions every game is usually much stronger than a deck that occasionally produces magical Christmas land openings.

So… how many lands SHOULD you play?

For most Commander decks:

36–38 lands

is usually the safest and healthiest range.

That covers the majority of:

  • casual EDH
  • mid power tables
  • upgraded precons
  • and most normal multiplayer games

If you’re newer to Commander, staying around:

37 lands

is honestly a very good starting point.

Why newer players often run too few lands

A lot of players copy decklists online without realizing something important:

High power and cEDH decks often cheat on land counts because they run:

  • fast mana
  • expensive staples
  • optimized mana bases
  • low curves
  • tons of draw
  • free interaction

If your deck does NOT have:

then trying to run 30–32 lands usually becomes much riskier.

And honestly, many casual players underestimate how punishing missed land drops are in multiplayer Commander.

Ramp does NOT automatically replace lands

This is another huge misunderstanding.

Players often say:

“I only run 33 lands because I have ramp.”

But ramp itself usually requires mana first.

Cards like:

still depend on having functional early turns.

A hand with:

  • 2 lands
  • several ramp spells

can still completely fail if you miss your next land drop.

Your mana curve matters a lot

This changes everything.

Lower curve decks

If your deck is very aggressive or optimized, you can often reduce lands slightly.

Especially if you run:

  • cheap interaction
  • fast mana
  • efficient draw
  • low average mana value

These decks sometimes function well around:

33–35 lands.

Big mana / battlecruiser decks

If your deck wants to cast:

you usually want MORE lands, not fewer.

These decks often feel much smoother around:

37–39 lands.

Missing land drops loses more games than flooding

This is something experienced players learn over time.

Flooding feels frustrating because:

  • you notice it immediately
  • it feels unlucky

But missing land drops is usually much worse.

Especially in Commander, where games often snowball heavily once players start developing faster than the table.

A player stuck on 3 mana while everyone else reaches 7 or 8 mana usually falls massively behind.

Utility lands are amazing… until they ruin your colors

Commander players LOVE utility lands.

And honestly:

  • they’re fun
  • powerful
  • flexible

But many decks become too greedy with them.

Cards like:

are strong.

But if your deck suddenly cannot produce the colors it needs, those utility lands start becoming liabilities.

Color consistency almost always matters more than cute utility effects.

One simple question helps a lot

When building your mana base, ask yourself:

“Can this deck reliably play Magic during the first 4 turns?”

If the answer is:

  • awkward
  • inconsistent
  • or dependent on perfect draws

you probably need more lands.

The internet often lies about land counts

This honestly needs to be said.

A lot of online decklists are:

  • greedier than they should be
  • optimized for very high budgets
  • tested in specific metas
  • or simply built by players gambling on consistency

Many real Commander tables become dramatically smoother by adding:

2 extra lands.

It sounds boring.
But it works.

Final thoughts

Most Commander players cut lands too aggressively because adding exciting cards feels more fun than adding consistency.

But reliable mana wins games.

For most EDH decks, staying around:

36–38 lands

is still one of the healthiest and most consistent approaches.

And honestly, if you’re constantly getting mana screwed in Commander…

the problem is probably not bad luck.

Back to blog