Commander mulligan guide for opening hands in Magic The Gathering

Commander Mulligans: when should you actually keep your opening hand?

Every Commander player knows the feeling.

You draw your opening seven, stare at the cards for five seconds, and immediately start negotiating with yourself:

“Okay… technically this hand could work…”

And then three turns later:

  • you missed your land drops
  • did absolutely nothing
  • and spent the whole game watching someone else cast Rhystic Study on turn two.

Learning when to mulligan is honestly one of the biggest differences between newer Commander players and experienced ones.

And surprisingly, it’s usually not about finding the perfect hand.

It’s about avoiding the terrible ones.

The biggest mistake Commander players make

Most bad keeps happen for one simple reason:

greed.

Commander players LOVE keeping risky hands because:

  • “I might draw into lands”
  • “This hand becomes insane if I topdeck one card”
  • “But look at this combo piece”
  • “I have Sol Ring though…”

Almost everybody does it.

And honestly?
Sometimes greed works.

But over many games, disciplined mulligans win far more consistently.

First question: can this hand actually play Magic?

This sounds obvious, but it immediately eliminates a huge number of bad hands.

Ask yourself:

Can I realistically cast spells during the first 3 turns?

Not:

“Can this hand become amazing later?”

But:

“Can I actually participate in the game early?”

In most Commander decks, you usually want:

That’s the safest starting point for most casual and mid-power tables.

Hands that are usually traps

1 land + hope

Everybody has kept these before.

Especially when the hand contains:

And sometimes it works.

But statistically?
These hands fail far more often than players remember.

Commander games feel terrible when you spend 4 turns doing nothing.

The “too many cool cards” hand

This one is incredibly common.

You draw:

  • huge bombs
  • powerful spells
  • expensive creatures
  • flashy combos

But:

  • no ramp
  • awkward mana
  • no early game

And your brain says:

“This hand is insane.”

No.
The cards are insane.

The hand is terrible.

Lands matter more than almost everything else

Newer players often underestimate this.

A boring hand with:

  • lands
  • ramp
  • decent curve

usually performs MUCH better than:

  • greedy explosive hands
  • combo-heavy hands
  • “all gas” hands

Commander is still a mana game at its core.

If your deck cannot function early, the rest of the cards barely matter.

The Sol Ring trap

This deserves its own section because it happens constantly.

Some players see:

and immediately keep the hand no matter what else is in it.

That’s dangerous.

A bad hand does not automatically become good just because it contains fast mana.

Sometimes:

  • you still have no colors
  • no card draw
  • no actual plays
  • or no way to convert that acceleration into pressure

Fast mana helps a hand.

It does not magically fix everything.

Another important question:

what kind of deck are you playing?

Not every Commander deck mulligans the same way.

Aggressive decks

Usually want:

  • fast starts
  • low curve
  • early pressure

These decks care a lot about:

  • tempo
  • early mana
  • curving out properly

Combo decks

Often mulligan more aggressively searching for:

  • setup pieces
  • tutors
  • ramp
  • protection

These decks can sometimes keep riskier hands because they care about specific combinations more than raw board presence.

Casual battlecruiser decks

Usually care more about:

  • stable mana
  • enough lands
  • surviving early turns

These decks normally benefit from safer keeps.

Commander mulligans are also psychological

This is something many guides never mention.

A lot of players keep bad hands because:

  • they fear going to six
  • they think mulliganing means “losing value”
  • they don’t want to look unlucky

But honestly?

A strong six-card hand is usually MUCH better than a terrible seven.

Especially in Commander, where the London Mulligan rule is very forgiving.

One simple rule that helps a lot

If your hand relies on:

“drawing perfectly”

to function…

you should probably mulligan.

Reliable hands win more games than magical Christmas land hands.

A solid Commander opening hand usually has:

  • enough lands
  • access to your colors
  • something to do early
  • reasonable curve
  • and a realistic game plan

It doesn’t need to be explosive.

It just needs to function.

Final thoughts

Good mulligans are less about finding the perfect hand and more about recognizing bad ones before the game even starts.

Most Commander players lose far more games from:

  • greedy keeps
  • awkward mana
  • and unrealistic hands

than from going down to six cards.

And honestly, once you start becoming more disciplined with mulligans, you notice the difference surprisingly fast.

Sometimes the strongest play in Commander happens before turn one even begins.




Back to blog